UK and EU carbon border rules reshape steel trade flows: EY

The introduction of carbon border adjustment mechanisms in the UK and EU is already reshaping steel trade flows, while significant differences between the two systems could delay reciprocal exemptions even if an agreement to link the carbon markets is reached, Alwyn Hopkins, UK and Ireland Industrials and Energy Sustainability Leader at EY, said on Nov. 19.

Aligning the UK and EU emissions trading systems would require changes to domestic legislation, carbon pricing and arrangements and administrative infrastructure before businesses could benefit from potential exemptions, Hopkins said at a conference held in London by think tank cbamboo.

The comments came ahead of the Nov. 20 UK-EU summit, where the two sides are expected to discuss linking their emissions trading systems, a move that could pave the way for mutual CBAM exemptions.

“I think there’s still a number of hurdles to jump through before we get to a point where we can argue that the CBAM regimes are comparable,” Hopkins said.

He highlighted differences in carbon prices, free allocation arrangements, emissions accounting and market stability mechanisms, suggesting that an Emissions Trading System linking agreement would not automatically translate into immediate CBAM exemptions.

Hopkins pointed to the EU-Swiss ETS linkage as a potential model, under which two separate emissions trading systems operate with mutually recognized allowances.

However, he said negotiations between Switzerland and the EU began in 2010, with the agreement entering into force only in 2020, illustrating the complexity of such arrangements.

Beyond the negotiations, Hopkins said CBAM was already influencing steel trade flows.

EU imports of iron and steel products in December 2025 were 65% above the average for comparable December periods in previous years, before falling 27% below the corresponding January average in January 2026, he said.

Hopkins suggested the movements reflected importers accelerating shipments ahead of the EU CBAM’s definitive phase on Jan. 1, 2026, to avoid additional carbon costs.

However, he cautioned that other trade measures, including steel safeguards and tariffs, could also have contributed to the fluctuations.

The implications of carbon border measures extend well beyond government revenues, he said, with changes in sourcing decisions and trade patterns potentially having a more significant economic impact.

Hopkins also highlighted differences between the UK CBAM, which will take effect Jan. 1, 2027, and the EU mechanism.

While the UK will initially apply common default emissions values regardless of country of origin, the EU uses country-specific defaults, resulting in potentially significant differences in carbon costs for steel imported from China, India or Algeria or others countries, for example.

The UK is expected to introduce country-specific default values from 2029.

The treatment of indirect emissions — particularly electricity used in electric arc furnace steelmaking — could also influence the competitiveness of different production routes, Hopkins said.

Responding to a question from a steel producer, Hopkins said emissions accounting rules could favor some technologies over others depending on whether indirect emissions were included.

He also warned that businesses remained insufficiently prepared for the UK’s upcoming CBAM, particularly smaller importers and companies with complex international supply chains.

In the absence of an agreement between the UK and EU, companies moving CBAM-covered products between the two markets could face duplicate reporting requirements and additional costs, although the treatment would depend on the goods’ origin and applicable carbon price relief.

Hopkins said carbon accounting was increasingly becoming a factor in industrial competitiveness rather than simply a regulatory reporting exercise.

“This is now becoming a competitiveness metric,” he said, adding that businesses would need to understand carbon exposure across their entire supply chains as carbon pricing and environmental regulations expand internationally.

Author: Annalisa Villa

Platts Logo

spglobal.com