ResponsibleSteel is developing and testing two bilateral calculation tools with the China Iron and Steel Association (CISA) and Europe’s Low Emission Steel Standard (LESS) that would allow steelmakers to assess the same emissions data against different low-emission steel standards, the organization said on Monday November 16.
The work will be followed by what ResponsibleSteel described as the world’s first steel-standards interoperability pilots in China, with initial results expected in 2027.
ResponsibleSteel, CISA and LESS together cover more than 60% of global steel production, according to a progress report published by ResponsibleSteel during the 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) in Antalya.
The report marks the next stage of interoperability agreements signed at COP30 in 2025, moving the work from standards alignment toward calculation tools, assurance mechanisms and pilot testing.
ResponsibleSteel said the two co-calculation tools would allow steel sites to use the “same data set” to calculate their decarbonization progress against thresholds used by different standards.
The organization said wider market adoption of the interoperability mechanisms is expected to follow the China pilots.
From COP30 agreements to practical tools
ResponsibleSteel signed separate memoranda of understanding with CISA and LESS during COP30 in November 2025.
Fastmarkets reported at the time that the agreements covered organizations representing around 60% of global steel production and included plans to develop conversion tools capable of translating emissions data between standards.
“ResponsibleSteel is building a global framework to enable comparability to underpin a global market in low-emission steel,” ResponsibleSteel Chief Executive Officer Annie Heaton said when the agreements were signed.
One year later, ResponsibleSteel said detailed bilateral comparisons have been completed between its requirements and China’s C2F Steel standard, and between its requirements and LESS.
The organization said the work examined commonalities and differences between the standards and informed proposed revisions to the ResponsibleSteel International Production Standard.
ResponsibleSteel said C2F and LESS are also pursuing revisions to their respective rulebooks.
A standalone ResponsibleSteel greenhouse gas (GHG) standard and certification program focused on decarbonization progress is planned for 2027, according to the November 16 report.
ResponsibleSteel has also started developing an interoperable assurance approach for audits where certification is intended to be recognized across more than one standard.
Price signals differ across markets
Fastmarkets price assessments show that both the definitions and pricing of lower-emissions steel currently vary across regional markets.
Fastmarkets assessed its green steel domestic flat-rolled differential to the hot-rolled coil (HRC) index in Northern Europe at €120-200 ($132-220) per tonne on November 12, unchanged week on week.
The Northern European assessment covers steel produced with combined Scope 1 (direct), Scope 2 (purchased energy) and Scope 3 (value chain) emissions of no more than 0.8 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of steel.
In the United States, Fastmarkets assessed its green steel domestic differential to US HRC at $0 per short ton on November 11.
The US assessment applies a maximum emissions threshold of 0.7 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of steel.
A zero differential means no separate green-steel premium was reflected over the underlying US HRC price in the Fastmarkets assessment.
The US market also differs structurally from many other steelmaking regions. Electric furnaces accounted for 71.3% of US crude steel production in 2025, compared with 45.8% in the European Union and 10.6% in China, according to the World Steel Association (worldsteel).
In Asia, Fastmarkets assessed its green steel import differential to HRC cfr Vietnam at $110-220 per tonne on November 13, unchanged week on week.
The Vietnam assessment applies a maximum Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 emissions threshold of 1.3 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of steel.
The three assessments are not directly comparable because they cover different regional markets, units, delivery bases and emissions thresholds.
They do show that neither the emissions criteria used to classify lower-emissions steel nor the premium visible in the market is uniform globally.
That variation is relevant to the interoperability work because producers and buyers need to understand how emissions performance calculated under one framework relates to another without requiring every standard to adopt the same threshold.
Fastmarkets reported on November 12 that demand for lower-emissions flat steel in Europe remained subdued, with market participants saying premiums were difficult to achieve consistently outside testing, project-based applications and longer-term transactions.
China pilots due in 2027
ResponsibleSteel said the first interoperability pilots will take place in China, with initial results expected in 2027.
The pilots are intended to test whether the calculation and assurance mechanisms under development can allow emissions performance to be recognized credibly across different standards, according to ResponsibleSteel.
China is central to the work because CISA represents the world’s largest steel-producing market.
China produced 960.8 million tonnes of crude steel in 2025, according to worldsteel, with 89.4% produced through the oxygen route and 10.6% through electric furnaces.
The large difference between China’s production structure and the US market, where electric-arc furnace (EAF) production dominates, also adds to the challenge of developing comparable low-emissions classifications across steelmaking routes.
ResponsibleSteel said its interoperability work supports a scrap-variable approach that recognizes differences in scrap availability and allows decarbonization progress to be measured across multiple production routes.
The Steel Standards Principles (SSP), a broader international effort to improve alignment between steel emissions-accounting frameworks, said in its COP31 progress statement that 67 organizations now endorse its principles.
The SSP said worldsteel has continued mapping more than 50 steel standards and initiatives across 35 criteria to identify commonalities, differences and areas where greater alignment may be possible.
ResponsibleSteel said the objective of its work with CISA and LESS is not to create a single global steel standard, but to enable credible comparison and recognition between different frameworks.
The organization said interoperable standards could allow certified lower-emissions steel to be recognized across jurisdictions while preserving different policy thresholds and market requirements.


